**- 1080p -**
Audio Track 1 (Default): English 2.0 FLAC
Audio Track 2: Japanese 2.0 FLAC
Audio Track 3: English 2.0 Commentary AC3 (ep11 only)
Subtitle Track 1 (Default): English Signs & Songs (.ASS)
Subtitle Track 2: English Dialogue [UTW/Kametsu] (.ASS)
Dual-audio remux featuring our own encodes and UTW TV dialogue as a base (added complete italics, adjusted the margins, added fades to match video). I (Scyrous) heavily modified UTW's signs and added a lot of my own TS, as well as two additional signs from Doki and Coalgirls' releases. OP kara and ED TL is a restyled version of Doki's release, with the OP being ktimed from scratch. TS in the signs & songs track has been edited to match the English dub.
Why is this video green? Did Coalgirls fix it, did you screw it up, or did you two use different sources?
E: ok, Tsundere is green too. I guess it's the source and CG fixed it.
@kuchikirukia
Other way around actually! Believe it or not, these are the correct colors. I triple checked, used multiple methods and asked several people. Feel free to download the BDMV and see for yourself. Both Yousei-raws and Coalgirls have wrong colors. I was surprised too since the ‘greenish tint’ would indicate otherwise, but nope, Yousei-raws and Coalgirls have warmer colors instead. The colors you see here are native BDMV colors.
**Edit to your reply:** and no, it’s not even a source issue. The level of green looks perfectly fine in the BDMV.
Kametsu vs Coalgirls:
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdlora/kametsuanohana-theflowerwesawt.png
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdlodr/01.anohana-theflowerwesawthatd.png
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdlori/kametsuanohana-theflowerwesawt.png
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdlogw/01.anohana-theflowerwesawthatd.png
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdlorw/kametsuanohana-theflowerwesawt.png
https://img3.picload.org/image/drcdloda/01.anohana-theflowerwesawthatd.png
It's not easy being green.
@kuchikirukia
Yup, thanks for providing proof so everyone can see Coalgirls has less green. The Kametsu images are the colors you see in the BDMV.
But next time please include Yousei-raws as well, since both of them didn't get the BDMV colors right. Unless you want to claim both of them ''fixed'' the colors by applying the exact same filtering back in 2011. Oh wait, you seem to ignore that point whenever it's brought up... and really, the vast majority of early 10bit encodes experienced the **exact** same color problem because of a bug in many h264 10bit builds at the time. You mean to tell me all of those BDMVs have green-shifted colors and that encoding has no absolutely part in it?
As I said, you can keep sticking your head in the sand all you want, but please stop spreading misinformation.
@kuchikirukia
You're tired of your one and only argument being ''but Kametsu has more green'', can't seem to refute *any* of the points I brought up, and now you've resorted to trolling to try and make up for it.
Yup, I'd say we're done here. =)
Why the heck did Coalgirls crop 8px of video? In any event, those images just shows that Coalgirls encode suffers from the x264 10-bit bug from the time it was encoded and that Kametsu has the proper intended colors which can also be seen on the BDMV and HDTV. You can cry "moar green" all you want, but the truth is Coalgirls is simply lacking the intended green due to the bug previously mentioned in the x264 10-bit build they utilized.
Sure, the colors are yellow, gray, red, blue, and brown instead of yellow-green, gray-green, muddy red, blue-green, and brown-green because it's "missing" the color green... which just happens to be present in everything that's green.
Maybe it's just me, but both of those versions legit have the exact same colors. The only difference I see is coalgirls cropped some of the picture. Maybe it's my monitor since it seems like other people can see a difference (calibrated asus pg279q).
@Slysoft
It depends on screen and video settings. I can see it on two of my screens but not on the other two. \o/ In any case, as pointed out, the "green" is an intended effect of the show and was on ALL sources: WEB, TV, and Blu-ray. The only releases with different colors are those that were encoded using a faulty x264 10-bit build from when 10-bit was first implemented in which it messed with greens...
So yeah, if you want the best video encode, go with the Kametsu release. It has the proper colors and doesn't have a big unneeded crop like Coalgirls did.
Comments - 20
Astral
kuchikirukia
Scyrous
kuchikirukia
AXZ
motbob
kuchikirukia
kuchikirukia
Scyrous
kuchikirukia
Scyrous
Koby
AC_
kuchikirukia
GasaiYuno
Slysoft
Koby
NazD1
alilice
HachiRokuNiSanKyu