This was encoded from the Italian BD release (both the best quality source and the correct framerate unlike most of the BDs that have been released), and this release includes the dub with “English” songs (enjoy that if it’s even possible).
NTSC, and because there may be some (old) audio/video peripherals that don’t play well with true 24p content.
Also most (BD) encoders don’t know what they are doing.
i see, so what fps do the bdmvs play at. are they sold at 24 then converted to 23.976 because ‘encoders’. or in this case only italians know their stuff?
It is actually is determined by physics and it dates back to cathode ray TV’s. The electron beam is scanned across the screen in two passes. It first scans the odd pixels and then the even pixels. In North America TV was broadcast with 525 horizontal rows. Which means each scan did 262.5 rows.
In North America each TV channel was given 6 MHz to broadcast it’s programs, of which about 4.5 MHz was usable. Picture was sent, and then a small gap and then audio was sent. When color programming came out, they had to somehow fit the color data in between the picture and audio.
The color signal was interfering with the normal picture. Using some complicated physics, you can get rid of the interference if the gap between the picture and color and the gap between color and sound are both odd integer multiples of the horizontal frequency divided by 2. Simplifying the expressions, you can find that you need an integer multiple time the horizontal frequency to equal 4.5MHz.
So, going back to our 525 rows. Your horizontal frame rate is the number of rows times the frame rate. So, we need a number that when multiplied by 525 becomes divisible into 4,500,000 (4.5 MHz). That number turns out to be 29.97. This is why TV is broadcast at 29.97 FPS.
Okay, now with that out of the way. The 23.976 comes into play when converting from the 24FPS that film cameras use to broadcast rates. 24x29.97/30=23.976. This is called a three-two pull down. Basically they are manipulating the frames in a way that is undetectable to the human eye so that they can match the frame rate of your TV.
ETA: This might seem like it doesn’t add up so I’ll add one last step. 23.976 happens to be exactly 4/5 of 29.97. These 4 frames can be stretched into 5 frames because of the way TV images are produced, and that is what allows the movie to be broadcast in 29.97.
Do you have a source for that herkz or what made you come to that assumption?
well, the master is 24 fps according to the italian company that released this movie. there’s also some pictures of the japanese production of the anime that show them working on it at 24 fps exactly.
why would a film ever be produced at 23.976
i mean, most of them are. this is the first one i’ve seen that isn’t.
all is left for me is “koe no katachi” and i can die in peace
better just die now because we’re not subbing it
why name it “your name”, everybody will search for “tkimi no na wa” anyway
fuck weebs. the english name is far more well known at this point.
i’ll think i’ll give [Commie] a chance this time
i’ve been waiting for a good-quality release of this shitkai movie anyway(even the director himself started hating it recently)
lol all movies are produced at 24 fps
it’s just that for some stupid reason 23.976 became a standard for blu-ray, so everybody is releasing in that framerate (with some exceptions, of course)
if you care so much about correct framerate, why not release everything in 24fps? modern audio resamplers are completely transparent, so there’s really nothing against doing so
Comments - 67
s4m3
there u go
motbob
Finally!!
herkz
nice meme
Tehe
This meme is ded already.
Tehe
This meme is already ded.
Pocsmas
Italian BD or Japanese BD?
herkz
Koby
Lunamaria
[Commeme] your meme.
Xeiros
Much Appreciated.
alaricobama
Uchiage hanabi next?
Astral
nice
Zastin
Thanks, now I can finally fall asleep in the middle of all 5 Shinkai movies
Mendokusai
yup ?
Aoi-chan
>Commie
chai
nice meme
IWishIWasALittleGirl
Good watch. Everybody get rekt.
keijo
How is the Italian BD different from the Japanese?
herkz
better video quality
correct framerate
Noko
>Commie
Zyzyx
Sweet. Time for another rewatch
keijo
Sorry for nagging but why is 24fps correct for this movie especially when 23.976 is more widely used?
Razeth
herkz best gal, bias Commie.
mantasb
Thanks
herkz
24 fps is correct because that’s what fps it was made at. i’m not sure how else to answer.
Mendokusai
so, Italian BD’s frame rate is 24?
Koby
Do you have a source for that herkz or what made you come to that assumption?
bertokeren
nice meme.
nicky_008
meme
Toogle
kresbayyy
君のミームは。
Your meme.
Kiyome
why would a film ever be produced at 23.976
Spectrum
why is everything at 23.976
Kiyome
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecine
ChibiGoku
NTSC, and because there may be some (old) audio/video peripherals that don’t play well with true 24p content.
Also most (BD) encoders don’t know what they are doing.
Spectrum
i see, so what fps do the bdmvs play at. are they sold at 24 then converted to 23.976 because ‘encoders’. or in this case only italians know their stuff?
Cumhail
Just google’d it
Aryma
all is left for me is “koe no katachi” and i can die in peace
Nala_Alan
why name it “your name”, everybody will search for “tkimi no na wa” anyway
ts92
^ this tbh
also why all lowercase
nicky_008
inb4 honorific meme
kseniasolo
posting for posting’s sake
eXmendiC
smh
dexster
thanks comeme.
herkz
obviously
well, the master is 24 fps according to the italian company that released this movie. there’s also some pictures of the japanese production of the anime that show them working on it at 24 fps exactly.
i mean, most of them are. this is the first one i’ve seen that isn’t.
better just die now because we’re not subbing it
fuck weebs. the english name is far more well known at this point.
eXmendiC
Weebs wouldn’t download Commie anyway :^)
Nala_Alan
well i would never think of searching for “your name” lol
herkz
guess that means you’re a dirty weeb
Aryma
at least not from you herkz anyway thank you for kimi no name for now :^)
Aryma
Kizu 3 hype :D
Kamiyan93
Thanks, herkzy.
Yep.
shaddrag
Nice
Velvetine
smh herkz
dartallis
Always a party here! :)
AnonBaiter
i’ll think i’ll give [Commie] a chance this time
i’ve been waiting for a good-quality release of this shitkai movie anyway(even the director himself started hating it recently)
xerxes
what the fuck
literally, did ANYONE ask for this
herkz
no one had to. who the fuck would sub stuff for weebs like yourself in CURRENT_YEAR?
Aryma
i ask herkz for that
ZippyDSMlee
Excellent work you glorious commie bastard, if weebs complain they can change the file name or edit the subs know I do! lulz
RozDa
The size is small !! Why ?!
meowchin
lol all movies are produced at 24 fps
it’s just that for some stupid reason 23.976 became a standard for blu-ray, so everybody is releasing in that framerate (with some exceptions, of course)
if you care so much about correct framerate, why not release everything in 24fps? modern audio resamplers are completely transparent, so there’s really nothing against doing so
kamikazilucas
is there an Italian rip with flac audio?
Hennyo
Thank you.
Hennyo
No idea why this has 63 comments, The subs do not work!! : ) Share and Download Noobsubs upload!
bishop_
Man i love the drama in the comments of this movie’s releases
Ingenioussubs
Thanks for this. Oh boy… This comment section really is something.
Yes, finally someone agrees.
Heimz
Will you do weathering with you to? Watching high quality animation + beautiful editing/typeset like this is really like eyes therapy for me.